Back to Maple Buttercream

All Reviews for Maple Buttercream

  • of Reviews

Reviews:

Most Helpful

Most Helpful

Most Positive

Least Positive

Newest

Gallery

Maple Buttercream

Ingredients

Ingredient Checklist

3 large egg yolks

1 cup pure maple syrup, best quality

2 sticks (1 cup) unsalted butter, cold, cut into small pieces

      Cook's Notes

The frosting can be refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 3 days. Bring to room temperature before using.

Gallery

Maple Buttercream

Maple Buttercream

Maple Buttercream

Maple Buttercream

Ingredients

Ingredients

  • 3 large egg yolks
  • 1 cup pure maple syrup, best quality
  • 2 sticks (1 cup) unsalted butter, cold, cut into small pieces

Directions

In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the whisk attachment, beat the egg yolkson high speed until light and fluffy, about 5 minutes; set aside. In a small saucepan setover medium-high heat, bring the maple syrup to a boil, and cook until it registers240 degrees on a candy thermometer, about 15 minutes. Remove from heat.

With the mixer running, slowly pour syrup down the side of the bowl in a slow, steady stream, until completely incorporated, about 1 minute. Continue beating until bowl is just slightly warm to the touch, 4 to 5 minutes. Add butter, one piece at atime, until thoroughly incorporated and the frosting is fluffy, about 4 minutes more.

      Cook's Notes

The frosting can be refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 3 days. Bring to room temperature before using.

Cook’s Notes

The frosting can be refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 3 days. Bring to room temperature before using.

Reviews (15)

Add Rating & Review

95 Ratings

5 star values:

                                  15

4 star values:

                                  17

3 star values:

                                  33

2 star values:

                                  25

1 star values:

                                  5

Load More Reviews

Reviews (15)

Add Rating & Review

95 Ratings

5 star values:

                                  15

4 star values:

                                  17

3 star values:

                                  33

2 star values:

                                  25

1 star values:

                                  5

Add Rating & Review

95 Ratings

5 star values:

                                  15

4 star values:

                                  17

3 star values:

                                  33

2 star values:

                                  25

1 star values:

                                  5

95 Ratings

5 star values:

                                  15

4 star values:

                                  17

3 star values:

                                  33

2 star values:

                                  25

1 star values:

                                  5

95 Ratings

5 star values:

                                  15

4 star values:

                                  17

3 star values:

                                  33

2 star values:

                                  25

1 star values:

                                  5
  • 5 star values:
  • 15
  • 4 star values:
  • 17
  • 3 star values:
  • 33
  • 2 star values:
  • 25
  • 1 star values:
  • 5

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

02/15/2016

                What is the yield on this recipe?

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

02/15/2016

                How much does this recipe yield?

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

11/24/2015

                Excellent buttercream.  Patience is the key here.  You need to slowly whip in the syrup so that you are incorporating a lot of air to make an emulsion.  Then slowly add a piece of butter one at a time and incorporate again to add a lot of air to the buttercream.  Mine came out perfect and took about a 1/2 hour to make.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

10/07/2015

                This recipe is fantastic, but it's difficult.  It took me two tries to get it right, but once I did, it was AMAZING.
                Use a medium saucepan, a good thermometer  (Thermapen!)  Don't rely on cooking times in recipes.  If your frosting came out like a glaze, it was probably too warm when you added the butter and your butter melted.  I found a hand mixer (even though it's a pain) incorporated the hot maple syrup more thoroughly than a stand mixer.  Cut your butter into TINY pieces, and keep it cold.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

07/07/2014

                Simply the best maple buttercream recipe! It is light and fluffy as whipped cream but has the awesome taste of maple syrup. Delicious! I did it with butter and pecans cupcakes and everyone loved it!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 1 stars

03/25/2014

                I have to agree with the first reviewer. I wouldn't recommend this recipe. My maple syrup boiled over multiple times and the frosting didn't come out thick at all. After leaving it in the fridge all night, it was still pretty thin. It was only a little thicker than a cake batter. Needless to say my cake is a little melty looking. I would definitely advise using a different recipe.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

11/17/2012

                I made this recipe exactly as stated in the recipe, so
                delicious! I made maple sugar cookies for place
                cards and used this frosting to pipe names on the them.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

03/09/2012

                Don't change this recipe!!  It is perfect and so delicious!!  It is smooth and velvety, similar to a Swiss Meringue Buttercream, and not meant to be as stiff as an American Buttercream; however, still a great consistency for decorating cupcakes. Unlike other buttercreams, the recipe calls for using cold butter when incorporating it into the buttercream.  I think this is perhaps where other reviewers ran into trouble.  Just keep whipping and the butter will stiffen. Try chilling, if necessary.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

11/01/2011

                This icing was perfect atop my pumpkin cupcakes. Yes, as many of you have stated, 2 sticks is a lot of butter, but you have to pair this icing with something that tastes good with a buttery topping. Spice cake is one such thing. I have to admit, though, that I added another half stick to get the consistency right. I started to add the icing sugar but I was afraid it would be too sweet. With the extra butter I was able to decorate with it. Everyone who tasted said it was divine! Best they'd had!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/24/2011

                Amabana is completely correct.. I made this recipe today using their changes and it turned out great! Before adding icing sugar, the frosting is waay too watery, but I'd definitely reccommend giving it a try with about 1.5 cups icing sugar, boiling the maple syrup at medium-low heat for about 7 minutes, and only adding one stick of butter.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/16/2011

                I'm pretty sure Martha doesn't know what pure maple syrup is (prob flavored corn syrup). I'm from Qc and after 15 minutes of cooking, my syrup was rock hard candy!! The second time around I lowered the heat and I reached 240* after 7 minutes but left it cooking on med-low until  ~10 minutes. 
                Secondly two sticks of butter is nasty tasting. I used ~1.3 and added icing sugar until I had a frosting consistency (~1.5 cups).
                I got great reviews from coworkers but its not easy to correct this recipe!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

11/24/2009

                This is the most amazing buttercream I have ever made...world class.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

10/08/2009

                I would definitely not recommend this recipe. The consistency is more of a glaze, not the fluffy deliciousness that is buttercream. Also, boiling the maple syrup is rather difficult, because it has a tendency to boil over extremely quickly unless you stir it, and stirring for 15 minutes ends up feeling like a very, VERY long time. Another detractor is that with TWO STICKS of butter, it just ends up tasting like butter, with only a tiny bit of maple syrup. I would suggest finding another recipe.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

10/07/2009

                2 STICKS OF BUTTER??? ARE YOU KIDDING ME??? If I'm going to go all out on a recipe, I'm going to use a better one than this. This frosting just tasted like pure butter.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/18/2009

                it's alright, over all, it is a waste of maple syrup

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

02/15/2016

                What is the yield on this recipe?

Rating: 5 stars

                How much does this recipe yield?

Rating: 5 stars

11/24/2015

                Excellent buttercream.  Patience is the key here.  You need to slowly whip in the syrup so that you are incorporating a lot of air to make an emulsion.  Then slowly add a piece of butter one at a time and incorporate again to add a lot of air to the buttercream.  Mine came out perfect and took about a 1/2 hour to make.

Rating: Unrated

10/07/2015

                This recipe is fantastic, but it's difficult.  It took me two tries to get it right, but once I did, it was AMAZING.
                Use a medium saucepan, a good thermometer  (Thermapen!)  Don't rely on cooking times in recipes.  If your frosting came out like a glaze, it was probably too warm when you added the butter and your butter melted.  I found a hand mixer (even though it's a pain) incorporated the hot maple syrup more thoroughly than a stand mixer.  Cut your butter into TINY pieces, and keep it cold.

Rating: Unrated

Rating: Unrated

07/07/2014

                Simply the best maple buttercream recipe! It is light and fluffy as whipped cream but has the awesome taste of maple syrup. Delicious! I did it with butter and pecans cupcakes and everyone loved it!

Rating: 1 stars

03/25/2014

                I have to agree with the first reviewer. I wouldn't recommend this recipe. My maple syrup boiled over multiple times and the frosting didn't come out thick at all. After leaving it in the fridge all night, it was still pretty thin. It was only a little thicker than a cake batter. Needless to say my cake is a little melty looking. I would definitely advise using a different recipe.

Rating: 1 stars

Rating: 5 stars

11/17/2012

                I made this recipe exactly as stated in the recipe, so
                delicious! I made maple sugar cookies for place
                cards and used this frosting to pipe names on the them.

Rating: Unrated

03/09/2012

                Don't change this recipe!!  It is perfect and so delicious!!  It is smooth and velvety, similar to a Swiss Meringue Buttercream, and not meant to be as stiff as an American Buttercream; however, still a great consistency for decorating cupcakes. Unlike other buttercreams, the recipe calls for using cold butter when incorporating it into the buttercream.  I think this is perhaps where other reviewers ran into trouble.  Just keep whipping and the butter will stiffen. Try chilling, if necessary.

Rating: Unrated

11/01/2011

                This icing was perfect atop my pumpkin cupcakes. Yes, as many of you have stated, 2 sticks is a lot of butter, but you have to pair this icing with something that tastes good with a buttery topping. Spice cake is one such thing. I have to admit, though, that I added another half stick to get the consistency right. I started to add the icing sugar but I was afraid it would be too sweet. With the extra butter I was able to decorate with it. Everyone who tasted said it was divine! Best they'd had!

Rating: Unrated

02/24/2011

                Amabana is completely correct.. I made this recipe today using their changes and it turned out great! Before adding icing sugar, the frosting is waay too watery, but I'd definitely reccommend giving it a try with about 1.5 cups icing sugar, boiling the maple syrup at medium-low heat for about 7 minutes, and only adding one stick of butter.

Rating: Unrated

02/16/2011

                I'm pretty sure Martha doesn't know what pure maple syrup is (prob flavored corn syrup). I'm from Qc and after 15 minutes of cooking, my syrup was rock hard candy!! The second time around I lowered the heat and I reached 240* after 7 minutes but left it cooking on med-low until  ~10 minutes. 
                Secondly two sticks of butter is nasty tasting. I used ~1.3 and added icing sugar until I had a frosting consistency (~1.5 cups).
                I got great reviews from coworkers but its not easy to correct this recipe!

Rating: Unrated

11/24/2009

                This is the most amazing buttercream I have ever made...world class.

Rating: Unrated

10/08/2009

                I would definitely not recommend this recipe. The consistency is more of a glaze, not the fluffy deliciousness that is buttercream. Also, boiling the maple syrup is rather difficult, because it has a tendency to boil over extremely quickly unless you stir it, and stirring for 15 minutes ends up feeling like a very, VERY long time. Another detractor is that with TWO STICKS of butter, it just ends up tasting like butter, with only a tiny bit of maple syrup. I would suggest finding another recipe.

Rating: Unrated

10/07/2009

                2 STICKS OF BUTTER??? ARE YOU KIDDING ME??? If I'm going to go all out on a recipe, I'm going to use a better one than this. This frosting just tasted like pure butter.

Rating: Unrated

09/18/2009

                it's alright, over all, it is a waste of maple syrup

All Reviews for Maple Buttercream

  • of Reviews

Reviews:

Most Helpful

Most Helpful

Most Positive

Least Positive

Newest

All Reviews for Maple Buttercream

  • of Reviews

Reviews:

Most Helpful

Most Helpful

Most Positive

Least Positive

Newest

Reviews:

Most Helpful

Most Helpful

Most Positive

Least Positive

Newest